Of course it's gonna get old. Make a smaller sandwich so you can eat it in one meal!

 

Try it with some Smuckers Red Plum jam...

 

i got some smuckers jelly that is like super runny. it taste's fine, but it's runny

 

 

Hahahaha I love Fluff and haven't had it in forever. I'm a Jif fan though cuz as they say Choosie moms choose Jif. Jif has always been in my house.

 

Peter Pan creamy FTMFW!

I was out of sorts when Conagra had to pull it off the shelves for a while. I just won't eat any other brand.

 

I've always had Peter Pan, until the salmonella scare, then it was Skippy. Never liked it before, but I did when I had to switch.

 

I like them all, but Peter Pan and Jif are my favorites.

One of the biggest disappointments of my entire life was the day I tried Reese's. I was expecting it to be the same "gritty" peanut butter they put inside Peanut Butter Cups. But I was wrong. So very, very wrong.

 

Jif and smuckers...

 

Smuckers is awesome, but I prefer grape on a PB&J. And if you're gonna go grape, you have to go Welch's. And when given the choice, I always go with the jam, not the jelly.

Dammit. Now I'm starving.

 

Welch's is always too watery for me.

 

I can see that. But what you call "watery" I call "spreadable."

 

Yes!!!! and it must be ice cold out of the fridge.

I like mine on regular old S&S sandwich wheat bread

 

I really miss the jam & peanut butter together in a jar Never see it here any more , but when in the USA I sometimes find some & bring a few back to shut people up that thought I was BSing about it !
I like bread & butter I like toast & jam. sounds like a song lol

 

Sure hope you butter both pieces of bread.

 

your sure it's jelly huh they could have been a diabetic and sometimes it can be fruity to smell , lol

 

Okay, I just checked the fridge. Currently we've got Smucker's grape jam on hand. Further study is needed, but I may very well have to revise my previous statement.

I should pay more attention! But to tell you the truth, when I'm hungry enough for a PB&J, I usually just grab the jars and go to town. It's all in the muscle memory at this point. I could probably do it in my sleep, if I haven't already.

 

 

Ice cold Smuckers Red Plum jam, Peter Pan peanut butter, and two pieces of really fresh honey wheat sandwich bread. I could eat three at any time!

Now I know what's for lunch tomorrow.

 

I'm mossy, Jerry. My brain is mossy. Listen to this idea... a restaurant that serves only peanut butter and jelly...