Manual vs. automatic - can't decide
#42
It is an issue in NYC & vicinity. You can drive for an hour & never get out of 1st or 2nd gear, constantly stopping & going & stopping.... After a year & a half of this, I was sorry I bought a stick. Wished I had gotten a AT. One week later, my car was totaled when a truck hit me. Then I got a automatic.
#43
Member
Join Date: December 21, 2009
Location: Southwestern USA
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm a SoCal folk, and a couple of my cars have been A/T. Having said that, I noticed I lost a bit of my spirit for driving when I owned them.
I now put up with the traffic and manual transmission. Though as has been mentioned, it's gruesome when you drag along 10 feet, stop, and repeat. But I'm blessed with minimal freeway driving while living in a big city.
I'm not sure if/when I'll ever go back to A/T.
OP: Get the M/T, and then graciously offer the wife a personal lesson in how fun driving a stick can be.
I now put up with the traffic and manual transmission. Though as has been mentioned, it's gruesome when you drag along 10 feet, stop, and repeat. But I'm blessed with minimal freeway driving while living in a big city.
I'm not sure if/when I'll ever go back to A/T.
OP: Get the M/T, and then graciously offer the wife a personal lesson in how fun driving a stick can be.
#45
Bullitt Member
Join Date: April 26, 2010
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 267
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm a SoCal folk, and a couple of my cars have been A/T. Having said that, I noticed I lost a bit of my spirit for driving when I owned them.
I now put up with the traffic and manual transmission. Though as has been mentioned, it's gruesome when you drag along 10 feet, stop, and repeat. But I'm blessed with minimal freeway driving while living in a big city.
I'm not sure if/when I'll ever go back to A/T.
OP: Get the M/T, and then graciously offer the wife a personal lesson in how fun driving a stick can be.
I now put up with the traffic and manual transmission. Though as has been mentioned, it's gruesome when you drag along 10 feet, stop, and repeat. But I'm blessed with minimal freeway driving while living in a big city.
I'm not sure if/when I'll ever go back to A/T.
OP: Get the M/T, and then graciously offer the wife a personal lesson in how fun driving a stick can be.
I think it all depends how you look at it. Will you get an automatic in anticipation of frustrating times in traffic? Or will you get a manual in anticipation of the chances when you can have a hell of a lot of fun? I choose the latter, therefore, I choose the 6speed. By the way, I live in LA. There are canyons all around for some fun times. Right now, I get bored driving an automatic, regardless of bumper-to-bumper traffic or open road.
#46
GT Member
Join Date: April 2, 2010
Location: Shizuoka City, Japan
Posts: 190
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
California stop-n-go is probably a lot different from Colorado stop-n-go. Literally, move up to 10 feet, complete stop. Move up 10 feet, complete stop. Move 50 feet, get a chance to throw it into second, complete stop. Or sometimes you're creeping along at 3 MPH, just slow enough that it's about to stall. Now imagine doing this for 30+ minutes. That is a pain in my book. Thankfully my commute has basically no traffic as I don't need to use the freeway.
#47
Shelby GT350 Member
#48
Bullitt Member
Join Date: March 3, 2010
Location: Niles, Mi
Posts: 314
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
All the what should "I" get threads are kind of useless. I can see asking what has better performance, but get what you want to drive. Auto or Stick, V8 or V6, what color, package etc. It's all a matter of personal preference. No ones any better than anyone else just because they have a manual or not.
It's you car and you are paying for, get whatever floats your boat.
It's you car and you are paying for, get whatever floats your boat.
#49
Legacy TMS Member
Join Date: January 25, 2010
Location: Massachusetts
Posts: 3,849
Received 1,573 Likes
on
1,078 Posts
My GT is my daily driver, I went with the manual, and I'm glad I did. You're buying a Mustang because it is fun to drive, right? The stick makes it a LOT more fun to drive than an automatic.
Your wife can learn to drive it too . . . you can be a patient teacher, right?
Or, then again, maybe she doesn't really need to drive the Mustang . . .
Your wife can learn to drive it too . . . you can be a patient teacher, right?
Or, then again, maybe she doesn't really need to drive the Mustang . . .
#51
Cobra R Member
Join Date: March 12, 2004
Location: Orange County, CA
Posts: 1,560
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#52
V6 Member
Join Date: April 26, 2010
Location: bham al
Posts: 88
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My wife and I both have manual transmission cars. And in less than two years, I will be teaching my son(hopefully) how to drive one.
I never had a problem driving a stick in rush-hour traffic. That is, until I got an overly stiff aftermarket clutch with a lightweight flywheel. In the summer, with the AC, I have *zero* torque at off idle, so it's a real pain in the *** to drive in the summer. But it was fine with the stock clutch/flywheel.
I never had a problem driving a stick in rush-hour traffic. That is, until I got an overly stiff aftermarket clutch with a lightweight flywheel. In the summer, with the AC, I have *zero* torque at off idle, so it's a real pain in the *** to drive in the summer. But it was fine with the stock clutch/flywheel.
#53
Stick with the 3.31 Option.... I have a GT but the new MT82 is so smooootthhh.... I think even a Honda Driver could handle it (Just kidding!).
Just tell her it was your dream car and you really dont want to compromise your dream. But you will be more than willing to teach her to drive it.
Go some where to an abandoned parking lot on a Sunday Afternoon and let her practice starting and stopping and then going up and down through the gears.
Then let her drive streets in a manufacturing district (light traffic on Sundays) and then just progress to more and more demanding situations.
If she gets tired stop for the day..... and never ever lose your temper. Just be patient.
Its my experience the issue with most is that they are afraid they will get overwhelmed in traffic. Letting them get comfortable before the traffic is the trick.
Just tell her it was your dream car and you really dont want to compromise your dream. But you will be more than willing to teach her to drive it.
Go some where to an abandoned parking lot on a Sunday Afternoon and let her practice starting and stopping and then going up and down through the gears.
Then let her drive streets in a manufacturing district (light traffic on Sundays) and then just progress to more and more demanding situations.
If she gets tired stop for the day..... and never ever lose your temper. Just be patient.
Its my experience the issue with most is that they are afraid they will get overwhelmed in traffic. Letting them get comfortable before the traffic is the trick.
Last edited by Gene K; 5/20/10 at 02:25 PM.
#55
GT Member
Join Date: June 10, 2008
Location: Ottawa, Canada, eh
Posts: 129
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The two valid reasons for a driving enthusiast to buy an automatic in a performance car:
-Physical impairment that prevents driving a manual
-Hardcore bracket racer
#56
I don't even care much about "fast car." I'm buying the V6, after all. I'm not going to be a race car driver, because that stuff doesn't matter to me (should I pay extra to buy a car that will go 160 MPH when I know realistically I'll never drive it above 80?). I've just always wanted a Mustang, and I've never even considered buying an auto version, because I love driving stick.
A little over a year ago I had a Ford Ranger, 5 speed manual. I really enjoyed driving the manual transmission. I have to lend my mother my car daily for certain reasons, she does not like driving a stick. So I offered to get a car I wanted in stick, but got it in auto so she could borrow it. Well it is getting to the point she wont need it anymore. I now have a car I wanted, in a transmission I did not want. I am looking to sell it in the future for a mustang in manual. If you really love it, get what you want, if you don't, you will regret it.
#58
My two cents..... Get an auto if the wife doesn't know how to drive stick. Avoid the embarrassment, maintenance (repairs), and real potential for an accident. Though stick IS a lot of fun, and it's nicer to drive than be driven.
#60
the trick of driving a manual equipped vehicle or really any car, is the less you step on any pedal, being brake, clutch, or accelerator, the easier it is to drive. nothing fatigues a driver more than constantly having to step on this or that pedal. in stop and go traffic, i use neutral as much as possible and the hand brake. when stopped at a red light, it's neutral again and the hand brake. on the freeway when there is room to cruise, i use the speed control buttons. on top of all this, you really need to pay attention to the traffic and road conditions and know when to back off the gas and also how hard to accelerate if you're just going to have to stop at the red light at the next corner. i'm 63 years old and i'm a retired accident investigator. i have been driving manual equipped cars since i was 15. i learned how to drive a clutch in the city of san francisco where there are lots of hills. as to traffic jams, they are all pretty much the same. though i have been living in southern california for 30 years, a traffic jam is a traffic jam. actually, one of the worst traffic jams i was in was on the freeway in the city of seattle. la's freeway jams are no worst than that.
ed
ed