Looks familiar:



I had a dent wizard type guy look at mine and he said it probably wouldn't look that great, so I had it done at a body shop. Hope you have better luck.

 

That would have almost purchased one new Shelby wheel. Hope it turns out good.

 

+1. My wifes 2006 VW Bug got a grocery cart in the passenger door when it was less than 6 months old. It did not crease the metal and did not scratch the paint. Much like yours. A "Dent Wizard" guy came to the house and worked that dent out for about 1 1/2 hrs. It cost $200 but I can only see where it was when the summer sun hits that door at the right angle and the car is perfectly clean. If your guy is a good one...you will be happy with the fix.
Scott

 

Sorry man, I feel your pain. I'm sure you'll see that it gets done right one way or another. Good luck.