How do you feel about your Tune?
#41
Bullitt Member
Thread Starter
Mark,
Your example is just one more on the list of people who's canned tunes did not work. As I've stated countless times, every car is different. With my experience tuning Camaros since the OBD I days, there is no way you can get me to run a canned tune. As the years go by, more and more current, i.e. S197, owners will go the "custom" route and will begin to tune their own cars as I do. Today, I'd predict that less than five percent of S197 owners write their own tune files. This estimate will only increase with time. I'm one of these because I want the absolute optimum tune for my car. As for your case, I'd seriously consider forking out the $$$ to buy the tuning software and learning about how to tune your own car!!! I can only imagine what it's like to totally depend on a tuner through e-mail . IMHO, tuning software should always be your first mod.
I've screen captured all the variables involved in Coasting Fuel Shutoff and the Knock Sensor parameters. As you can see, this is not as simple as it may seem. But if you had the software, you can examine all the scalars and tables from your current tune file and compare them with the stock tune file values. By creating a value file of your stock coasting and knock sensor parameters, then importing them into your current tune file, you'll know without a doubt if the tune file is the culprit....
Your example is just one more on the list of people who's canned tunes did not work. As I've stated countless times, every car is different. With my experience tuning Camaros since the OBD I days, there is no way you can get me to run a canned tune. As the years go by, more and more current, i.e. S197, owners will go the "custom" route and will begin to tune their own cars as I do. Today, I'd predict that less than five percent of S197 owners write their own tune files. This estimate will only increase with time. I'm one of these because I want the absolute optimum tune for my car. As for your case, I'd seriously consider forking out the $$$ to buy the tuning software and learning about how to tune your own car!!! I can only imagine what it's like to totally depend on a tuner through e-mail . IMHO, tuning software should always be your first mod.
I've screen captured all the variables involved in Coasting Fuel Shutoff and the Knock Sensor parameters. As you can see, this is not as simple as it may seem. But if you had the software, you can examine all the scalars and tables from your current tune file and compare them with the stock tune file values. By creating a value file of your stock coasting and knock sensor parameters, then importing them into your current tune file, you'll know without a doubt if the tune file is the culprit....
#42
Willie, I may have to go this route. I'm good with a computer so I have to fear from the pc aspect of this. Are you using the "Pro Racer" software? Do you know where I can buy just the software. I already own a flash device. What I don't unerstand with the tune is that my car is all stock except for the Steeda CAI. Ford has one generic program that they put on their cars (manul vs auto) those "oem" tunes are cookie cutter but they work. Why is it that mail order tunes from Bama or Brenspeed are subject to pinging or whatever on stock cars???
#43
Team Mustang Source
Matt: You mention that you have had tunes from several of the reputable vendors. Can you tell us what tunes you liked the best, or if there was not much difference??
#44
Really there is not a whole lot of difference. They are all very good, each has its own little flavor...brenspeed pulls more in 2nd than bamas does but bamas pulls harder in 3rd than the others. You will not be dissappointed in any tune that you get from these guys IMO.
#45
Bullitt Member
Thread Starter
The tune I have is from one of the big names on this forum and it wakes the car up, no question, the car rips
with the 93 tune. But if I go WOT in pings like an SOB and I know the gas is good. I just need to work through the issues but I can't help but wonder what sensors and parameters have been changed. Just becuase you don't here pinging doesn't mean it's not there detonation does not have to be audible. That's one of the things I'm worried about. I need to get this machine on a dyno.
with the 93 tune. But if I go WOT in pings like an SOB and I know the gas is good. I just need to work through the issues but I can't help but wonder what sensors and parameters have been changed. Just becuase you don't here pinging doesn't mean it's not there detonation does not have to be audible. That's one of the things I'm worried about. I need to get this machine on a dyno.
#46
Mach 1 Member
Join Date: October 14, 2006
Location: Tucson, Arizona
Posts: 716
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
....Are you using the "Pro Racer" software? Do you know where I can buy just the software. I already own a flash device.
Yes. I believe all SCT dealers can sell the software. I think today's going price for the software alone is $349. Shop around. Having a licensed copy gives you some privileges. You can request access to SCT's Pro Racer forum. There's some good stuff on there not available to everyone else. I also recommend buying a training video from:
http://www.lasotaracing.com/
It will definitely give you a major head start in creating your own tune files, tweaking and datalogging tips and tricks.
Willie
Yes. I believe all SCT dealers can sell the software. I think today's going price for the software alone is $349. Shop around. Having a licensed copy gives you some privileges. You can request access to SCT's Pro Racer forum. There's some good stuff on there not available to everyone else. I also recommend buying a training video from:
http://www.lasotaracing.com/
It will definitely give you a major head start in creating your own tune files, tweaking and datalogging tips and tricks.
Willie
#47
so Mark I advanced my timing 2 degrees on my 93 tune because I use 94 octane gas. SO even if im not hearing anything it could still possibly damagaing my engine. I dont reallly feel any power cut except a few times, but i think that may be another problem mentioned here on the forum. Im not even sure what kind of pinging I should be listening for. Would it be noticeably audible?
#48
The tune I have is from one of the big names on this forum and it wakes the car up, no question, the car rips
with the 93 tune. But if I go WOT in pings like an SOB and I know the gas is good. I just need to work through the issues but I can't help but wonder what sensors and parameters have been changed. Just becuase you don't here pinging doesn't mean it's not there detonation does not have to be audible. That's one of the things I'm worried about. I need to get this machine on a dyno.
with the 93 tune. But if I go WOT in pings like an SOB and I know the gas is good. I just need to work through the issues but I can't help but wonder what sensors and parameters have been changed. Just becuase you don't here pinging doesn't mean it's not there detonation does not have to be audible. That's one of the things I'm worried about. I need to get this machine on a dyno.
I need to stress here, that the CAI setup (90MM lighting MAF, stock sensor, and Saleen Extreme intake tube) are pieces that Doug has NEVER seen in combination before, so the back-and-forth is not normal, but an example of what a good custom tuner can (and should) do...
I THINK that the next version will be the final one, unless Doug wants more data. Right now, the car pulls very hard from idle all the way to redline, the AT shifts hard enough to wiggle the rear end (285/40-18 Nitto 555s!) going into second, and chirp firmly hitting third. Drivability is excellent, in all RPM ranges. If you mystery tuner is Doug, drop him an email, I feel confidant that he will help you out, especially if you can datalog for him, with AFR. If you mystery tuner is NOT Doug, then drop him an email anyway. $75 for a tune is cheap when it comes down to it. MY mystery tuner was charging $175 for the same service.
IF you don't have a wideband that can feed your tuner to allow datalogging, then that's the next thing you NEED to do. Even if you're bang-on perfect, the peace of mind will be worth it. If you're not, then that will really help your tuner dial in to the specific adjustments that need to be made.
In the end, I really can't say enough about Doug's tuning, AND his customer service. Yes, it takes him a couple days or more to respond on occasion, but so what? He's still better at getting me what he promised than my former tuner who answered the phone instantly...
#49
IF you don't have a wideband that can feed your tuner to allow datalogging, then that's the next thing you NEED to do. Even if you're bang-on perfect, the peace of mind will be worth it. If you're not, then that will really help your tuner dial in to the specific adjustments that need to be made
#50
I know a lot of guys get their mailorder tunes dyno-tweaked locally and have mentioned pulling out one of the O2 sensors to insert the wideband sensor. Which O2 sensor do you pull? Does the wideband screw into the hole or is it just a probe that fits loosely? Wouldn't temporarily removing an O2 sensor cause the engine to run bad and throw a CEL?
#51
mail order tunes are unreliable. my bamachips tune made my car stall upon idle , shoot black smoke, and it was unable to run for weeks. i finally got it towed to a performance shop. the tune from doug was running EXTREMELY lean. dyno tunes in my opinion are the ONLY way to go about tuning these cars. not to mention customer service was lack luster with bamachips. he had no idea what to do about my car.
#52
I know a lot of guys get their mailorder tunes dyno-tweaked locally and have mentioned pulling out one of the O2 sensors to insert the wideband sensor. Which O2 sensor do you pull? Does the wideband screw into the hole or is it just a probe that fits loosely? Wouldn't temporarily removing an O2 sensor cause the engine to run bad and throw a CEL?
#53
I have the Steeda CAI and Steeda program. This is the only tune I have tried so I have nothing else to compare it to. All I can say is there is a HUGE performance increase and the car runs as smooth as stock. When I install the CMDP's I will use their updated program for that mod as well. I'm not sure I want to try someone elses tunes or not.
#54
I'm not sure I want to try someone elses tunes or not.
#55
mail order tunes are unreliable. my bamachips tune made my car stall upon idle , shoot black smoke, and it was unable to run for weeks. i finally got it towed to a performance shop. the tune from doug was running EXTREMELY lean. dyno tunes in my opinion are the ONLY way to go about tuning these cars. not to mention customer service was lack luster with bamachips. he had no idea what to do about my car.
Everyones car is different and reacts differently. You are in the minority that had problems. Dyno tunes are the best but that is not an otion for everyone, especially when you add a few mods here and there and then have to go back everytime. Good dyno tuners are few and far between. I would trust Doug or Brent before some of the hacks out there that do tuning.
#56
Really there is not a whole lot of difference. They are all very good, each has its own little flavor...brenspeed pulls more in 2nd than bamas does but bamas pulls harder in 3rd than the others. You will not be dissappointed in any tune that you get from these guys IMO.
#58
I have to completely disagree with you....there are very few people that run into problems....as stated before I have run pretty much everyones and never had any problems at all. The majority of people have no problems though, you only hear about the ones that dont work because if it works, not everyone is going to make a post to say...."wow, the tune worked just like it should have."
Everyones car is different and reacts differently. You are in the minority that had problems. Dyno tunes are the best but that is not an otion for everyone, especially when you add a few mods here and there and then have to go back everytime. Good dyno tuners are few and far between. I would trust Doug or Brent before some of the hacks out there that do tuning.
Everyones car is different and reacts differently. You are in the minority that had problems. Dyno tunes are the best but that is not an otion for everyone, especially when you add a few mods here and there and then have to go back everytime. Good dyno tuners are few and far between. I would trust Doug or Brent before some of the hacks out there that do tuning.
I have the Brenspeed 91 octane tune. I notice some soot in the pipes, but nothing serious. The performance advantage is undeniable, I noticed an immediate increase in power and throttle response, and I dropped almost 1/2 a second off of my 1/4 mile time.
For 600$ (tune + CAI), you can't beat that.
#59
Team Mustang Source
Join Date: May 25, 2005
Location: Skopje, Macedonia
Posts: 1,267
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Like Kobie, I have the Steeda tune and CAI. I have had no problems, pings, or CEL's. I do have sootie exhaust pipes which would indicate a rich condition but from what I have read here thats not so bad in itself.
#60
so Mark I advanced my timing 2 degrees on my 93 tune because I use 94 octane gas. SO even if im not hearing anything it could still possibly damagaing my engine. I dont reallly feel any power cut except a few times, but i think that may be another problem mentioned here on the forum. Im not even sure what kind of pinging I should be listening for. Would it be noticeably audible?
If you think your fuel ratio is off, then also datalog STFT (short-term fuel trim) and LTFT (long-term fuel trim) for banks one and two, and take a look at those. They will tell you if the car is running lean or rich, compared to the commanded AF ratio as determined by the tune. STFT values under 1.000 indicate a lean condition (expressed in percentage from 1.000), while over indicates a rich condition (also expressed in percentage from 1.000). LTFT are scaled the other way, with values under 1.000 indicating rich, and over 1.000 indicating lean.
Best is to include a wideband O2 sensor reading as well, but that won't be free if you don't already have one installed.