I was able to buy two rear mats from accmats.com that are custom fit and match the color and carpet style perfectly. Best part is they were less than $30 including shipping. To be honest though, you really can't even see the rear mats when they're installed so it wouldn't be very noticeable even if the color or texture of the carpet were off a bit.

 

I purchased them from the Ford dealer... about $60.00. Email 05stangkc, he can probably get you a better deal

 

See if you look at the pics I posted yours look like a better fit. I know someone makes them that are not oem that look like yours. Who knows, I guess I will buy them and If I dont like them EBAY

 

The pony mats were just to small... I went with these at americanmuscle.com

Attachment 25316