I get that.
End of discussion is no, saddle does not show nor collect dust and faster than any other leather.

 

What? Have you personally owned and tested every type of Leather on the market?

Without proper care that saddle interior is going to look as grey and scoffed up as an air cooled 964 eBay special with tan interior. Take care of her!

 

I treat it and clean it, but he just made it sound like it's a dust magnet and it'll show dirt as easy as black paint.

I love the color and people are always like "wow!" when they see it, really adds a luxury touch to the car.