Loud clunk when shifting from 1-2
Loud clunk when shifting from 1-2
Hi everyone,
I just picked up my 5.0 Thursday night and spent a couple hours today driving around town breaking in the engine. I'm at about 150 miles right now and I noticed the transmission is not nearly as smooth as my other car (02 Maxima SE 6spd). I noticed that in the Mustang, if I'm stopped at a light and make a turn left or right, and then shift from 1-2 while turning and accelerating, there is a very noticeable clunk coming from the clutch when I press in the clutch (note if I'm driving straight, the clunk doesn't really happen or is minimal). Is this normal?
On another note, I noticed what seemed like rattling coming from the exhaust around 2500rpm this morning when I started driving, but this seemed to go away as soon as everything heated up.
I found a small cut in the leather on the passenger's seat (pic attached) so I need to take the car in to get the seat repaired and want to make sure I get any other problems fixed. Please let me know if the clunkiness with the clutch is normal in the situation I described.
I just picked up my 5.0 Thursday night and spent a couple hours today driving around town breaking in the engine. I'm at about 150 miles right now and I noticed the transmission is not nearly as smooth as my other car (02 Maxima SE 6spd). I noticed that in the Mustang, if I'm stopped at a light and make a turn left or right, and then shift from 1-2 while turning and accelerating, there is a very noticeable clunk coming from the clutch when I press in the clutch (note if I'm driving straight, the clunk doesn't really happen or is minimal). Is this normal?
On another note, I noticed what seemed like rattling coming from the exhaust around 2500rpm this morning when I started driving, but this seemed to go away as soon as everything heated up.
I found a small cut in the leather on the passenger's seat (pic attached) so I need to take the car in to get the seat repaired and want to make sure I get any other problems fixed. Please let me know if the clunkiness with the clutch is normal in the situation I described.
these transmissions are designed to shift reliably at 7000rpms. its difficult to design blocking rings that a smooth when shifting a low rpm/part throttle AND allow 7k shifts.
with that said, i dont personally like it that mine clunks at low roms either. they will also periodically grind a gear at part throttle also. they seem to like shifting hard even around town. ie, go from gear to gear quick and not easy.
with that said, i dont personally like it that mine clunks at low roms either. they will also periodically grind a gear at part throttle also. they seem to like shifting hard even around town. ie, go from gear to gear quick and not easy.
these transmissions are designed to shift reliably at 7000rpms. its difficult to design blocking rings that a smooth when shifting a low rpm/part throttle AND allow 7k shifts.
with that said, i dont personally like it that mine clunks at low roms either. they will also periodically grind a gear at part throttle also. they seem to like shifting hard even around town. ie, go from gear to gear quick and not easy.
with that said, i dont personally like it that mine clunks at low roms either. they will also periodically grind a gear at part throttle also. they seem to like shifting hard even around town. ie, go from gear to gear quick and not easy.
Mine is a little clunky as well, doesn't bother me though
I scratched the side bolster and tore the perforated leather slightly on my 400a seat back from the snap of an open pocket on my shorts! That "leather" is THIN!
Mine has more of what I'd call a slight "crunch" going into second and third when it's cold. Not really a concern however, or the same thing.
Some clunks from the driveline too at low speeds when working the clutch, pretty normal for these cars due to the driveshaft design I believe.
Mine has more of what I'd call a slight "crunch" going into second and third when it's cold. Not really a concern however, or the same thing.
Some clunks from the driveline too at low speeds when working the clutch, pretty normal for these cars due to the driveshaft design I believe.
Yeah, I get some clunks in my '10 when shifting up and down at low speeds / light throttle, I always thought it was from play in the drivetrain combined with my less-than-perfect throttle/clutch/shift technique -- if I keep the drivetrain always loaded in the same direction, it doesn't do it.
Last edited by Bert; Sep 12, 2010 at 03:57 AM. Reason: typo / more
Thanks everyone for all the replies! You've definitely put my mind at ease regarding the tranny. Regarding the seat, I've already emailed my salesman the pic above and I'm going to absolutely insist they completely redo that section of the seat. Since the car just came from the dealer a few days ago I'm not going to accept any patch work that they might try and recommend.
Dealer should fix this seat tear. Ours did!
Thanks everyone for all the replies! You've definitely put my mind at ease regarding the tranny. Regarding the seat, I've already emailed my salesman the pic above and I'm going to absolutely insist they completely redo that section of the seat. Since the car just came from the dealer a few days ago I'm not going to accept any patch work that they might try and recommend.
The mt82 may be made in china, but it is built by german getrag. I have been in another getrag plant, and you could eat off the floor. One of the cleanest industrial plants i have seen, and i have been in many in my travels with at&t.
I have drivetrain lash, but i think the transmission may work out alright.
I have drivetrain lash, but i think the transmission may work out alright.
Last edited by tstrick9; Sep 12, 2010 at 08:21 AM. Reason: spelling
Yea mine grabs a bit between 1st and 2nd as well. I notice it seems to go away when it gets warmed up, and when shifting higher.
I'm right around 2000 miles now, so I dont anticipate it getting any better. But since most other people are experiencing the same thing, I'm not too worried.
My '02 GT grabbed a bit between 1st and 2nd, but way worse than this new one.
I'm right around 2000 miles now, so I dont anticipate it getting any better. But since most other people are experiencing the same thing, I'm not too worried.
My '02 GT grabbed a bit between 1st and 2nd, but way worse than this new one.
The mt82 may be made in china, but it is built by german getrag. I have been in another getrag plant, and you could eat off the floor. One of the cleanest industrial plants i have seen, and i have been in many in my travels with at&t.
I have drivetrain lash, but i think the transmission may work out alright.
I have drivetrain lash, but i think the transmission may work out alright.
Mine is really pretty smooth most all the time, the only thing I've really noticed is the bloody skip shift, which... does things. I'm still not clear what, but I note that around that period where it flashes up the skip shift it's like the shift from 1-2 is rather difficult, but not impossible, and is very clunky as a result. Now I may just happen to pull the shift **** back relatively firmly, as I have read that you can force it into second anyway despite the skip shift, and I will say that if I try to shift gears with purposeful gentleness it does seem like there's something guiding the stick into 4th instead of 2nd.
Anyway, that was the only thing I noticed. Other than that, my transmission shifts wonderfully smooth as far as I know, but take that with a grain of salt, my experience with manual transmissions with extremely limited. This is the only manual I've driven for more than 20 minutes.
And if we want to talk build days, if there's a difference I doubt it's much, but for what it's worth mine was built in May, and as far as I know was in the quality control hold around that time, for whatever the reason ended up being. It was off site for about a week.
Anyway, that was the only thing I noticed. Other than that, my transmission shifts wonderfully smooth as far as I know, but take that with a grain of salt, my experience with manual transmissions with extremely limited. This is the only manual I've driven for more than 20 minutes.
And if we want to talk build days, if there's a difference I doubt it's much, but for what it's worth mine was built in May, and as far as I know was in the quality control hold around that time, for whatever the reason ended up being. It was off site for about a week.
Hi everyone,
I just picked up my 5.0 Thursday night and spent a couple hours today driving around town breaking in the engine. I'm at about 150 miles right now and I noticed the transmission is not nearly as smooth as my other car (02 Maxima SE 6spd). I noticed that in the Mustang, if I'm stopped at a light and make a turn left or right, and then shift from 1-2 while turning and accelerating, there is a very noticeable clunk coming from the clutch when I press in the clutch (note if I'm driving straight, the clunk doesn't really happen or is minimal). Is this normal?
On another note, I noticed what seemed like rattling coming from the exhaust around 2500rpm this morning when I started driving, but this seemed to go away as soon as everything heated up.
I found a small cut in the leather on the passenger's seat (pic attached) so I need to take the car in to get the seat repaired and want to make sure I get any other problems fixed. Please let me know if the clunkiness with the clutch is normal in the situation I described.
I just picked up my 5.0 Thursday night and spent a couple hours today driving around town breaking in the engine. I'm at about 150 miles right now and I noticed the transmission is not nearly as smooth as my other car (02 Maxima SE 6spd). I noticed that in the Mustang, if I'm stopped at a light and make a turn left or right, and then shift from 1-2 while turning and accelerating, there is a very noticeable clunk coming from the clutch when I press in the clutch (note if I'm driving straight, the clunk doesn't really happen or is minimal). Is this normal?
On another note, I noticed what seemed like rattling coming from the exhaust around 2500rpm this morning when I started driving, but this seemed to go away as soon as everything heated up.
I found a small cut in the leather on the passenger's seat (pic attached) so I need to take the car in to get the seat repaired and want to make sure I get any other problems fixed. Please let me know if the clunkiness with the clutch is normal in the situation I described.
You sure it is not the skip shift trying to engage? Trying to make a left or right turn behind traffic usually keeps me right around the skip shift rpm's. But if you take your time when you shift it will still go into second but it will be clunky. The skip shift will disengage again as rpms drop under there parameters. It may be during this process that you are trying to shift into second before it has fully disengaged.



