would this look right
IMHO, I would think the color would have to match perfectly, or be way way off to look good. I have gone down this road, and I ended up getting polished wheels. I think they go great, but if it is not the look you are going for, I understand. Oh, and did I mention they are for sale? 

For some reason the anthracite Shelby Razors seem to blend well with many of the Mustang "greys". I've seen them on Mineral Grey and it's hard to tell it's not a perfect match.
Here's a gorgeous GT500 (looks Tungsten to me). Perfect
Here's a gorgeous GT500 (looks Tungsten to me). Perfect




